Posted by kemanuel
Merry Christmas, everyone!!! And Happy New Year!!
I hope everyone had a wonderful holiday! Personally, Christmas was wonderful for my family. I actually took some days off. And our 9-year-old girl received way too many presents. Plus, I learned that we should be spending way less on her!! We bought her a new saddle, bridle and breast-strap for her horse, but, when asked what she received for Christmas, she tells everyone about the $2 marshmallow gun she received, not the saddle. Regardless, we were able to spend quality time together with my mom and dad and 2 sisters. My husband Scott, however, got the flu and he has been in bed for the last few days…yuck! But he was healthy on Christmas.
We have been truly blessed this year, and I want to thank you all for reading my blog.
I received an email today from an owner of a home care agency that reminded me that, especially during the holidays, many people are struggling. This home care agency owner, “we will call him Al,” informed me that he potentially will be closing his agency, which would put approximately 130 employees out of work. Al told me that his agency has been struggling over the past few years with the decrease in personal care services (PCS) reimbursement rate.
Al is not the only home care agency owner who has contacted me in the last few months bemoaning about the low PCS reimbursement rates. The PCS reimbursement rates are set by legislature, most of the time in the budget bills. For example, the General Assembly passed the budget this past year, which will decrease the PCS reimbursement rates by another 3% beginning January 1, 2015. (Happy New Years).
See below, which is from another blog post: “PCS Medicaid Reimbursement Rates Are TOO LOW to Maintain Adequate Quality of Care, in Violation of the Code of Federal Regulations!”
“SECTION 12H.18.(b). During the 2013-2015 fiscal biennium, the Department of Health and Human Services shall withhold reduce by three percent (3%) of the payments … on or after January 1, 2014” (emphasis added).”
The PCS reimbursement rate became $13.88. Session Law 2014-100 was signed into law August 7, 2014; however, Session Law 2014-100 purports to be effective retroactively as of October 2013. (This brings into question these possible recoupments for services already rendered, which, in my opinion, would violate federal and state law, but such possible violations (or probable or currently occurring violations are a topic for another blog).
It is without question that the Medicaid reimbursement rate for PCS is too low. In NC, the PCS reimbursement rate is currently set at $13.88/hour (or $3.47/15 minutes). It is also without question that there is a direct correlation between reimbursement rates and quality of care.
Because Medicaid pays for approximately 67% of all nursing home residents and recipients of home health care in USA, the Medicaid reimbursement rates and methods are central to understanding the quality of care received by PCS services and the level of staffing criteria expected.
PCS for adults are not a required Medicaid service. As in, a state may opt to provide PCS services or not. As of 2012, 31 states/provinces provided PCS services for adults and 25 did not. Most notably, Florida, Virginia, and South Carolina did not provide PCS services for adults. See Kaiser Family Foundation website.
According to Kaiser Family Foundation, “For the personal care services state plan option, the average rate paid to provider agencies [across the nation] was $18.19 per hour in 2012, a slight increase from $17.91 per hour in 2011. In states where personal care services providers were paid directly by the state or where reimbursement rates were determined by the state, the average reimbursement rate was $16.31 per hour in 2012. Medicaid provider reimbursement rates are often set by state legislatures as part of the budget process.”
What can be done regarding these low PCS reimbursement rates in NC???
In order to change legislation, one of two avenues exist: (1) lobbying; or (2) litigation.
Over the past few years, while the PCS reimbursement rates have continued to decrease, the associations involved with home care organizations and long term care facilities (companies that provide PCS) have emphasized the lobbying aspect. No litigation has been filed demanding a reasonable PCS reimbursement rate.
Obviously, the lobbying aspect has yielded less than desirable results. Instead of increasing the PCS reimbursement rate, the General Assembly has continually decreased the rate.
When one line of attack does not work, you try another.
Maybe it is time for litigation.
Posted in Adult Care Homes, Assisted Living Facilities, Division of Medical Assistance, General Assembly, Health Care Providers and Services, Home Health Aide Services, Home Health Care Agencies, Home Health Services, Hospice, In Home Care Services, Lawsuit, Legal Remedies for Medicaid Providers, Legislation, Long Term Care Facilities, Medicaid, Medicaid Attorney, Medicaid Reimbursement, Medicaid Reimbursements, Medicaid Services, Medicare Attorney, NC, NC DHHS, North Carolina, Personal Care Services, Rate Reductions, Shared Saving Plan, State Budget
Tags: 3% Cost Sharing, Budget, Division of Medical Assistance, Home Care Agency, Home Care Workers, home health, Home Health Services, Kaiser, Lobbying, Medicaid, Medicaid Attorney, Medicaid Reimbursement Rate, Medicare Attorney, NC DHHS, North Carolina, PCS, PCS Rate Reductions, PCS Reimbursement Rates, Personal Care Services, Session Law 2014-100, State Budget